Collectibles & Luxury Marketplaces: The Hidden Revenue in Every High-Value Transaction

Jun 30, 2025

Marketplaces that deal in collectibles and luxury goods operate in a uniquely high-stakes environment. Every transaction involves an item with personal or market value that often goes beyond typical consumer goods. A $10,000 watch, a graded trading card, or a rare pair of sneakers represents not just a purchase but an investment.

In these moments, buyers want to feel confident, and sellers want protection. But most platforms aren’t designed to address the risks that come with these high-value exchanges. As a result, trust breaks down. Transactions stall. Support teams spend valuable time resolving disputes. Revenue growth slows as fees become harder to increase and buyer drop-off rises.

Embedded insurance offers a practical, scalable solution. It creates financial protection at the point of purchase, improves the experience for both sides of the transaction, and opens up new ways for platforms to grow revenue without adding friction.

What is Embedded Insurance?

Embedded insurance is offered at the time and place a customer is making a purchase decision involving risk. In the context of marketplaces and luxury resale platforms, this usually means offering optional coverage at checkout to protect the item during shipping or throughout ownership.

Rather than redirecting users to a third-party insurer or relying on inadequate homeowners policies, embedded insurance keeps the insurance experience contained within the platform itself. This integration can be simple, branded, and digital-first.

Why Traditional Insurance Doesn’t Fit

Most insurance products are not designed for the nature of collectibles or one-of-a-kind luxury goods. Standard policies often:
  • Base payouts on depreciated or replacement value, not true market value
  • Exclude items lost or damaged during shipping or stolen post-delivery
  • Require extensive documentation and manual claims processes
This creates a critical gap, where many collectors think they’re covered and they’re actually not. When something goes wrong, it is often the platform, not the insurer, that is left to manage the fallout.

Embedded insurance solves for this by offering coverage tailored to the needs of these transactions, including in-transit protection and fast, digital claims handling.

Embedded Insurance as a Revenue Growth Tool

While insurance is often seen as a service or safety net, in marketplace platforms it can also function as a monetization engine.

First, it generates high-margin revenue per transaction. Most embedded insurance products are opt-in and fee-based (premiums average 1-2% of the purchase price), which means platforms can earn a share of every policy sold. Importantly, this occurs without increasing core buyer or seller fees, making it a neutral or even positive experience for all parties.

Second, it improves conversion rates. When buyers see that they have the option to protect their investment, they feel more confident following through on the transaction. The presence of insurance reduces last-minute hesitation, particularly on higher-value items. Over time, this reduces cart abandonment and increases order volume.

Third, it increases average transaction value. Buyers who feel protected are more likely to make larger investments. Just as free returns encourage customers to buy more in traditional e-commerce, embedded protection can encourage collectors to move from $500 purchases to $5,000 purchases. The perceived risk becomes manageable, which leads to greater engagement and bigger orders.

Revenue Beyond the Initial Sale

In the world of collectibles and luxury goods, the journey doesn’t end after the first sale. These items are often held, traded, resold, and even passed down—sometimes appreciating in value over time. That makes the ownership lifecycle far more dynamic than traditional e-commerce.

Embedded insurance tailored to collectibles is designed with this in mind. Coverage can extend beyond the initial transaction and renew throughout the life of the item. Whether the buyer is holding the item for a year, listing it for resale, or trading it peer-to-peer, the insurance can continue to protect its market value.

For platforms, this unlocks a long-term opportunity. Rather than capturing value only at the original point of sale, they can generate recurring revenue at each stage of the item’s life. Every time a policy is renewed or transferred, the platform can continue to participate financially—while providing buyers and sellers with peace of mind that their asset is protected.

This model turns static transactions into ongoing engagement. It aligns the platform’s revenue strategy with the real behaviors of collectors and enthusiasts, supporting a more sustainable and diversified business over time.

Operational Benefits

The financial upside of embedded insurance is only part of the picture. These solutions also provide operational relief. When something goes wrong in a high-value transaction, the burden often falls on marketplace support teams. Shipping disputes, lost packages, and damaged items lead to difficult conversations and time-consuming case reviews.

When buyers and sellers have access to coverage with a clear claims process, platforms are no longer forced into the role of mediator. Trust improves, satisfaction scores rise, and internal resources can be focused on growth rather than dispute resolution.

Key Considerations for Platforms & Marketplaces

For platforms considering embedded insurance, here are a few things to keep in mind when considering a potential embedded insurance partner:

Purpose-Built Products

Choose products designed specifically for collectibles and luxury goods. This includes valuation based on market price and door to door protection (and beyond).

Seamless Customer Experience

The right partner will be able to advise you on the perfect placement for the insurance offers so there’s no disruption to your user experience or checkout flow.

Conversion Optimization

Your embedded insurance partner should give you access to a partner portal to offer the ultimate transparency in tracking conversion rates and performance in real-time.

Claims & Customer Support

A true partner will handle all claims, customer support, and compliance regarding the insurance offers – reducing overhead and ensuring the best customer experience.

The Bottom Line

Embedded insurance is more than an add-on. It is a way to reduce friction, build trust, and unlock new forms of growth. In a category where every transaction carries emotional and financial weight, the ability to offer seamless protection can be a defining advantage.

For marketplaces and platforms in the collectibles and luxury resale space, now is the time to look beyond core fees and traditional monetization models. Embedded protection allows you to grow revenue while improving the experience for everyone involved.

Find out how your marketplace or platform can make it easier for your customers to protect what they love.

Learn More